1 of 45

Slide Notes

DownloadGo Live

Copy of Users want better (and so do librarians)

Published on Nov 18, 2015

How can we optimize the user experience through the management of a library's electronic resources?

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

User behaviour & managing e-resources

'Cause you can't have one without the otherRoën Janyk, MLIS, Okanagan College
Photo by Leon Fishman

Intro

Examples of issues

Scenario 1

So....?

Scenario 2

Alternate to ISSN? (& shouldn't someone contact the publisher?)

DOI?

Photo by mbstuart

How users search

Photo by Stéfan

Analytics to inform

Photo by writetoreply

Average session 8 m 30 s
1.77 result page views
6.2 pages per session

Time after search 3:34
About 1:37 on a page
39% use refinements

Off-campus reps majority
95% access via desktop

What can be done at the interface level?

Photo by liquidnight

Create visual interfaces

Photo by lanx1983

Improve scannability

Photo by Anna's Photos

Example

Remove barriers to off-campus access

Use Responsive Designs

Photo by jiraisurfer

Easily report linking issues

It becomes apparent that library holdings data stands at the center of all access problems
Photo by jenny downing

What if...

Example: Hover IL information, embedded report an issue

What do we need from our systems?

Photo by Equaliser

Flexible systems

In 2004 Breeding said, "To date, no single product exists that provides comprehensive management of electronic resources, including both front-end and back-end functions." More than 10 years later, we are looking for the same functionality.

Flexible systems = Library admin, vendor, & publisher/provider access

Access to system settings

What do you do when you are leasing content rather than purchasing to own?
Photo by PKMousie

+ Customization
(like ranking)

Getting around the "appropriate copy" problem:
Given that many resources are available through multiple sources, knowing which version to link to is a problem. It would be unfortunate for the link to point to the article in one resource it could have been accessed through another with more success.

Maybe I want to choose to display the publisher link because the user will be able to see vivid images, whereas the native database link is only HTML. What happens when we can't make this judgment call?

Accurate holdings

Volatile nature of aggregated electronic journal products, as well as database content and ownership


Photo by Sr. X

Open Systems = Interoperability & Adjustability

In 2004, Breeding said, "the many facets of electronic resource management should be delivered through a set of interconnected modules that work together, sharing common data files or at least communicating with each other through open protocols."

Open CUFTS knowledgebase -
For example:
CUFTS makes holdings available as a XML file for harvesting. EBSCO runs a script twice a week that harvests our EBSCO holdings. The script then takes the multiple XML files, combines them into one, and then loads the file to EBSCO's FTP server. This file is then added into a local collection in EBSCOadmin. EDS uses this local collection as a knowledge base to know what titles are in our holdings.

So yes we HAVE 2 knowledgebases, but we only manage 1 :)
Photo by cogdogblog

+ Ability to clean up metadata

Photo by amygwen

How do we get there?

Photo by blmiers2

Standards
to promote collaboration

Photo by tanakawho

NISO Standards

  • Open Discovery Initiative (ODI)
  • Presentation & Identification of E-Journals (PIE-J), Journal Article Tag Suite (JATS), Protocol for Exchanging Serial Content (PESC)
  • Knowledge Base and Related Tools (KBART)
  • NISO Access & License Indicators
  • Etc...
Photo by Amöbe

Clean metadata & linked data

Photo by gabitogol

CUFTS + EDS =
Managing 1 Knowledgebase

Photo by Onno B.

Automated Reporting

I want to know when users are turned away
I want auto renewal reports when licenses are going to end
I want notifications of title list updates

Assessing Impact

What is the impact electronic resource management has on users?

How can we optimize the management of e-resources if we don't know what the issues are?

Look to longitudinal user behavior

Photo by Vvillamon

Analytics & Statistics

Discovery Service analytics, EZproxy logs and login pages, trends over time

Usage reports, turnaway reports, clickthroughs

Clickthrough example

Almost...

Our e-resources management practices deeply impact our users!