¿Falsificación o arte?

El caso Beltracchi y sus consecuencias

Untitled Slide

Untitled Slide

Untitled Slide

Untitled Slide

Untitled Slide

Untitled Slide

Beltracchi

• 6 años de cárcel
• 20 millones de euros
• Sigue en el mercado
• 50% de sus ingresos se emplean para compensar a los perjudicados

Untitled Slide

Untitled Slide

Untitled Slide

Trasteco vs. Lempertz

LG Köln

• 2.80.000 Eur devolución
• 2.000.000 Eur
• Culpa in contrahendo!
• blanco titanio..
• informe artístico y científic

Diligencia debida

• información de la vendedora, firma e informe artístico no son suficientes
• confianza legítima en la casa de subastas

¿y ahora?

Condiciones

• 4. Warranty claims are excluded. In the event of variances from the catalogue descriptions, which result in negation or substantial diminution of value or suitability, and which are reported with due justification within one year after handover, Lempertz nevertheless undertakes to pursue its rights against the seller through the courts; in the event of a successful claim against the seller, Lempertz will reimburse the buyer only the total purchase price paid. Over and above this, Lempertz undertakes to reimburse its commission within a given period of three years after the date of the sale if the object in question proves not to be authentic. 5. Claims for compensation as the result of a fault or defect in the object auctioned or damage to it or its loss, regardless of the legal grounds, or as the result of variances from the catalogue description or statements made elsewhere are excluded unless Lempertz acted with wilful intent or gross negligence; the liability for bodily injury or damages caused to health or life remains unaffected. In other regards, point 4 applies.

Condiciones II

• 5. Claims for compensation as the result of a fault or defect in the object auctioned or damage to it or its loss, regardless of the legal grounds, or as the result of variances from the catalogue description or statements made elsewhere are excluded unless Lempertz acted with wilful intent or gross negligence; the liability for bodily injury or damages caused to health or life remains unaffected. In other regards, point 4 applies.

Ansorena

• https://www.ansorena.com/subastas/condiciones
• La autoría y/o atribución de las obras está basada en la experiencia, leal saber de la Sala y/o consulta con los diferentes expertos en cada autor y/o Escuela en el momento de la realización del catálogo. No haciéndose ANSORENA S.A. responsable de las opiniones contradictorias futuras de los expertos.

Gracias! jsuderow@deusto.es