1 of 23

Slide Notes

DownloadGo Live

Culture and Media

Published on Feb 03, 2020

No Description

PRESENTATION OUTLINE

Culture and Media

Photo by Ashes Sitoula

Universal

 Gender roles in culture are the same worldwide
Photo by Sandy Millar

Jobs, tasks and duties

 Division of labour is universal - culture plays little role

Changing roles

 Therefore can't be biology, must be due to culture 
Photo by Scott Webb

Mead Vs. Freeman

Culture Vs. Genetics
Photo by @Doug88888

Arapesh (mead)

 Men and Women were cooperative & gentle - both feminine
Photo by Julia Caesar

Mundugumor (Mead)

 Men and women were violent and competitive - both masculine
Photo by scott1346

Tchambuli (Mead)

WOMEN WERE DOMINANT, MEN WERE SUBMISSIVE - REVERSE GENEDER ROLES

All findings are different

 nurture, different tribes, different gender roles
Photo by davisco

EVALUATIONS

Photo by ChrisIrmo

CRITICISMS OF MEAD

FLAWED EVIDENCE, OBSERVER BIAS, FALSE BEHAVIOUR FROM TRIBES
Photo by l a n g g i

GENDER DIFFERENCES IN CONFORMITY

WOMEN ARE MORE CONFORMIST THAN MEN - VARIES ACROSS CULTURES. DIFFERENCES ARE HIGH IN SEDENTARY SOCIETIES

ALTERNATIVE EXPLANATION FOR CULTURAL DIFFERENCES IN CONFORMITY

WOMEN WHO CONTRIBUTE TO FOOD HAVE MORE FREEDOM - OCCUPY HIGH POSITION, MORE POWER

WEALTH MAY RELATE TO CHANGE IN EQUALITY

MORE WEALTH = MORE EQUALITY. SUPPORT BY EARLY AND WOOD - SOCIETIES WITH HIGH STATUS WOMEN = LESS FEMALE LABOUR
Photo by Pest15

ISSUE OF RESEARCH IS CULTURAL BIAS

WESTERN CONCEPTS, WESTERN STEREOTYPES - IMPOSED ETIC, DIFFERENT MEANINGS IN OTHER CULTURES - VALIDITY ISSUES
Photo by nur_h

MEDIA

Photo by mkhmarketing

MEDIA CAN INFLUENCE GENDER ROLE DEVELOPMENT

VICARIOUS REINFORCEMENT, ADOPT PARTICULAR BEHAVIOURS, SELF-EFFICACY EXPECTATIONS. MEN ARE PORTRAYED AS INDEPENDENT, WOMAN INEFFICIENT

NATURE OR ADS?

MEN CONTROL EVENTS IN ADS, WOMEN ARE SHOWN AS PASSIVE (CONLEY AND RAMSEY 81)

COUNTER STEREOTYPING

MEDIA CAN PRESENT COUNTER STEREOTYPES - REDUCE CHILDREN’S ADHERENCE TO TRADITIONAL STEREOTYPE ROLES

EVALUATIONS

Photo by ChrisIrmo

RESEARCH SUPPORT: NOVOTEL STUDY - TV AND GENDER STEREOTYPES

COMPARED STEREOTYPES BEFORE AND AFTER INTRODUCTION OF TV. BECAME MORE STEREOTYPED. MEDIA PLAYS A ROLE

EFFECTS OF MEDIA INFLUENCE ARE OVERSTATED

DOESN’T CHANGE ATTITUDES, REINFORCES THE STATUS QUO, LITTLE CHANGE IN GENDER STEREOTYPES OVER 30 YEARS AS A RESULT OF MEDIA EXPOSURE

COUNTER-STEREOTYPING CAN HAVE A BACKLASH

EXPOSURE TO NON-STEREOTYPED BEHAVIOUR STRENGTHENS STEREOTYPES RATHER THAN LESSENS THEM