We used rubrics developed with library staff and Comp II instructors.
Link to the rubric: http://bit.ly/1APv48b
The rubric was adapted from: Oakleaf, Megan, Michelle S. Millet, and Leah Kraus. “All Together Now: Getting Faculty, Administrators, and Staff Engaged in Information Literacy Assessment.” portal: Libraries & the Academy 11.3 (2011): 831–852. Print.
The peer assessment consisted of an evaluation form based on:
Fielden, Ned, and Mira Foster. “Crossing the Rubricon: Evaluating the Information Literacy Instructor.” Journal of Information Literacy 4.2 (January 2, 2010): vii–90. Print.